When Manolete uses the wrong procedure: what Hayward means for directors

November 19, 2026

Commentary. Simon Burn Solicitors did not act in this case.


When Manolete Partners buys a claim from a liquidator or administrator, it steps into the officeholder's shoes, but not completely. The court has made clear that an assignee does not inherit every procedural route the officeholder had. If a claim is issued the wrong way, a director may have grounds to challenge it, and that can shift the balance of a negotiation.


The leading decision on the point is Manolete Partners plc v Hayward and Barrett Holdings Ltd and others [2021] EWHC 1481 (Ch).


What happened


Manolete took an assignment of claims arising from the insolvency of Blackwater Plant Limited. Among them were claims against the company's directors for breach of their duties. Manolete issued everything in a single insolvency application in the Insolvency and Companies Court.


That was common practice at the time. An insolvency application is quicker to issue and carries a far lower court fee than an ordinary claim under Part 7 of the Civil Procedure Rules, which can cost up to £10,000 to issue for larger claims.


Two of the respondents challenged the procedure. They asked the court to require Manolete to pay the Part 7 issue fee or have its claim struck out. The case came before Chief Insolvency and Companies Court Judge Briggs, who gave judgment on 2 June 2021.


What the court decided


  • An assignee cannot bring a misfeasance claim under section 212. Section 212 of the Insolvency Act 1986 lets a liquidator, the official receiver, a creditor or a contributory apply to court. A litigation funder that has bought the claim is none of these.
  • Assigned claims for breach of directors' duties belong in Part 7. They are the company's own causes of action, not insolvency proceedings, so they must be issued by Part 7 claim form rather than insolvency application.
  • There was no "established practice" exception. The court rejected the argument that long-standing use of insolvency applications for these claims made the procedure acceptable.
  • The defect was cured on terms, not fatal. Rather than striking the claim out, the judge allowed it to continue on condition that Manolete paid the full Part 7 issue fee within seven days.


In a separate application, one respondent tried to strike out the allegation that he was a de facto director. That failed: whether someone acted as a de facto director is a question of fact for trial.


The approach in Hayward has since been followed. In Re Park Regis Birmingham LLP [2025] EWHC 139 (Ch), the court again insisted on separate proceedings, though it used its discretion to let a defective claim continue. The Insolvency Service has said it is considering whether the Insolvency Rules should change, but no amendment has been made.


What it means if Manolete is pursuing you


Hayward will rarely end a claim on its own. The court cured the defect by making Manolete pay the proper fee. But procedure is still worth checking from the first day, for three reasons.


  1. Cost and pressure. Manolete's model depends on keeping costs down and settling quickly. A challenge that forces a higher issue fee, separate proceedings or a re-pleaded claim raises its costs and can change its appetite to settle.
  2. Weaker heads of claim. If a section 212 claim has been brought by an assignee, that part of the claim has no proper basis and should be challenged.
  3. Leverage in negotiation. A director who can show the claim is procedurally flawed negotiates from a stronger position than one who engages only on the merits.


These are points to raise early and precisely, not technicalities to save for trial. We considered the Hayward point when acting for Mr Brafman, where we went on to have a default judgment obtained by Manolete set aside (see our case study: webeatmanoletepartners.org/case-study-2). Every claim we review is checked for how it has been issued as well as what it alleges.


Frequently asked questions


Can Manolete sue me for misfeasance under section 212?

Not as an assignee. Hayward held that section 212 is open only to a liquidator, the official receiver, a creditor or a contributory. Manolete can still pursue the company's own claims for breach of duty, but by Part 7 claim.


Does a procedural mistake mean the claim fails?

Usually not. Courts generally allow the claim to continue once the defect is put right, often on paying the correct fee. The value lies in cost, delay and negotiating leverage rather than in defeating the claim outright.


I have received a letter of claim but no court papers yet. Does this matter now?

Yes. How Manolete frames its claim in correspondence often shows how it intends to issue. Raising procedural points early, in the response to the letter of claim, gives them the most weight.


Facing a claim from Manolete?


We act only for directors, never for liquidators, administrators or funders, and we have been defending directors since 2004. For a free, no-obligation assessment of your claim, call 01242 228 444 (Cheltenham) or 0121 371 0301 (Birmingham), or get in touch via the contact page.


This article is general information, not legal advice on your circumstances. It reflects the law as at October 2026.

More latest news

June 8, 2026
Wrongful trading explained, defence strategies, and how webeatmanolete won a £6.5M High Court case.
June 8, 2026
Wrongful trading explained, defence strategies, and how webeatmanolete won a £6.5M High Court case.